As a result of the U.S. Department of Justice ramping up enforcement of the Foreign Agents Registration Act, Skadden Arps Slate Meagher & Flom LLP’s became one of the agency’s first milestone targets. The law firm’s $4.6 million disgorgement deal with the DOJ marks a new era of enforcement for the political and legal sectors. The firm failed to register its lobbying and public relations work for the Ukrainian government in connection with former Trump campaign chairman Paul Manafort, and then misled DOJ investigators about it, according to the agency. As part of the deal, Skadden will also have to retroactively register as a foreign agent.
“Law firms don’t want to be the cautionary tale, and Skadden is the cautionary tale here,” said Joshua Rosenstein of Sandler Reiff Lamb Rosenstein & Birkenstock PC, another D.C. attorney with FARA expertise. “I think ever since the initial Manafort and [Manafort associate Rick Gates] indictments, most of us who practice this area of law were waiting for the next shoe to drop and wondering where it was going to be.
Robert Mueller is reviving the Foreign Agents Registration Act, bringing nearly a half dozen indictments utilizing the law in cases related to Russian efforts to influence the 2016 presidential campaign.
Josh Rosenstein, a lawyer with expertise in FARA compliance, said the Justice Department typically has followed its formal policy of encouraging voluntary compliance over prosecution. The rare instances in which violations led to prosecution, Rosenstein said, have been high-profile cases involving unfriendly regimes.
“FARA has been dangled as both a carrot and a stick as part of a negotiation for a plea,” Rosenstein said.
Just days into the new Congress, K Street is seeing an influx of recently departed lawmakers and aides announcing new lobbying gigs. Recently departed members and staff bring with them fresh connections on Capitol Hill, but they also face restrictions on what they can do in the private sector.
Lawmakers and their aides are subject to a one-year ban on aiding or advising foreign governments or foreign political parties with the intent to influence the U.S. government, said Joshua Rosenstein, a partner with Sandler Reiff Lamb Rosenstein & Birkenstock, who specializes in lobbying and ethics laws.
Though recently departed lawmakers and their aides have long sought ways to get around the restrictions, Rosenstein said such matters are getting more attention with recent criminal convictions of people who engaged in unregistered lobbying, such as former Trump campaign chairman Paul Manafort, as well as House Democrats’ pending political overhaul (HR 1) that includes campaign finance, lobbying and ethics matters.
“This may be a different environment than what we had even a year ago,” Rosenstein said. “Public scrutiny is on the rise in terms of advocacy on behalf of foreign clients. And in my view, K Street in general has been treading more carefully in recent months.
A new law designed to require financial disclosure by Russian media outlets in the U.S. will potentially force more transparency in the operations of media companies headquartered in Qatar, including Al Jazeera English. The new law would require Al Jazeera English to file periodic reports with the Federal Communications Commission disclosing some information about the financial and operational control exerted over those broadcasters by parent companies abroad.
Despite this new law, however, the FCC has not received any registrations from either a Qatari or Russian media outlet. Only two broadcasters have registered to date.
Joshua Rosenstein, a lobbying and FARA compliance attorney with the firm Sandler Reiff, called the relatively few registrations “surprising, particularly given the breadth of the statute.”
“To me,” Rosenstein told The Daily Beast, “the dearth of reporting signals a combination of factors: lack of awareness of this small provision stuck into a massive bill; consternation and disagreement by state-run media over mandatory disclosure in general; [and] a lack of understanding of how the two laws might overlap.”
Authorities have indicted two former associates of Michael Flynn for acting as illegal agents of the Turkish government in the United States.
Partner of the firm, Josh Rosenstein, comments on these indictments and the role of cooperation in FARA prosecutions.
“Cooperation is a very big part of it,” said Josh Rosenstein, a partner at Sandler Reiff Lamb Rosenstein & Birkenstock who specializes in fara requirements. “One reason there have been so few fara indictments and prosecutions historically is because it is often used as a bargaining chip as part of pre-prosecution agreements.”
Capitol Media Group, a firm that was part of a controversial foreign influence operation that allegedly ensnared veterans into lobbying on behalf of Saudi Arabia, filed its first FARA supplemental statement on record with the U.S. Department of Justice.
Capitol Media Group filed its first supplemental statement with DOJ on October 30, 2018. However, the supplemental statement included a slew of inconsistencies. For example, the statement appears only to cover the six-month period ending September 30, 2018, more than a year after their lobbying activities took place, and there are payments reported to the veterans as opposed to the hotels or other businesses that benefited from the money.
Joshua Rosenstein, an attorney with Sandler Reiff Lamb Rosenstein & Birkenstock, called it “positively bizarre.”
Rosenstein said he is less concerned with why the supplemental statement was filed more than a year after the activities took place than other “substantive problems such as inconsistencies between the supplemental statement and initial filings as well as areas where “all of the boxes that are left blank.”
Ravi Singh, an Illinois-based political consultant, has challenged a federal law barring foreign involvement in U.S. elections, alleging the provision is unconstitutional. Although Mueller has yet to charge anyone with a direct violation of this law, the federal bar has played a role in his investigation and his team alludes to the statute in several legal filings.
A ruling in Singh’s favor could create more uncertainty with the Mueller investigation and in the greater effort to shield U.S. elections from foreign influence.
“It shows there is a lot of untested ground surrounding the foreign national prohibition,” said Joe Birkenstock, a former Democratic National Committee general counsel now with law firm Sandler Reiff.
Dara Lindenbaum, Senior Counsel at Sandler Reiff, is representing Stacey Abrams in a close election for the governor of Georgia. You can read about it here.
Aryeh Lightstone, a current State Department official, helped Elliott Broidy, a top fundraiser for Trump, arrange meetings with U.S. senators and Angolan officials in early 2017. However, neither Lightstone nor Broidy registered as a foreign agent. Some legal experts argue that Lightstone and Broidy should have registered with the government for the Angolan meetings, under the Foreign Agents Registration Act.
Joshua Rosenstein comments,
“Arranging meetings between a foreign government and U.S. government officials to discuss the foreign policy of the U.S. vis-à-vis a foreign government or to discuss the relationship between the U.S. and the foreign county would in my view count as political activities requiring registration,” said Joshua Rosenstein, a FARA specialist at the law firm Sandler Reiff.
An increasing number of public companies in the past several years have voluntarily opted to disclose corporate donations above and beyond what is required by the law. Josh Rosenstein comments on the implications reporting these contributions may have for companies.
“If you disclose that you have given to a [social welfare organization] or other independent expenditure group, and that intermediary in turn supports a candidate on the far right on the far left, there has to be and there is a concern that your business will take a hit, either by a boycott or otherwise, simply because the country is so polarized,” he said.
In addition, Rosenstein said, when a company plays in the political-contribution space and opts to make public disclosures about that involvement, it should have a robust compliance program that ensures it follows its own obligations regarding political spending and involves political law experts, whether in-house or outside.